← Free resourcesGet the toolkit

Free tool · 5–10 minutes

The Root Cause Reality Check

What to check before you accept “human error” as a root cause. Five questions, six areas to brainstorm, and a verification table that turns potential causes into confirmed ones.

Use this when

  • The root cause field says “human error”, “operator error”, “insufficient training”, or “procedure not followed”
  • The corrective action is retraining, and nothing else
  • You’re reviewing NCs and CAPAs before an audit
  • You need to challenge a weak root cause with something better than a feeling

The rule

A person’s mistake is where an investigation starts. It’s rare that the person’s behavior was the root cause.

You need to check the system around the person — and document what you found.

Most events have more than one contributing cause. You want to find the weaknesses that allowed the error, and the gaps that let it through undetected. Only then can you identify root causes.

In a hurry

If you’ve only got five minutes

  • Circle the root cause if it says “human error”, “operator error”, “training”, or “procedure not followed”
  • Check the problem statement doesn’t already name a cause
  • Read the two most likely of the six areas
  • Write one table row for each potential cause you see — with the action that would verify or disprove it

Take the toolkit with you

If you’ve done everything right, you’ve narrowed your potential causes down to the most relevant ones. What’s left is picking the ones that make the most sense to tackle, and then choosing actions that are not “retraining”.

Two patterns in the toolkit’s weak-pattern library deal with this: “human error” as the root cause and retraining as the default action, each with a weak and an improved example. Subscribers get:

Delivered by email, along with the MedTech CAPA Journal: frameworks for NCs and CAPAs that solve the problem and hold up in an audit. No fluff. Unsubscribe anytime.

Your team’s CAPAs keep ending in “human error” and retraining? See the in-house training